FIVE POSSIBLE PATHS FOR 21ST CENTURY CHURCHES

BY MARTIN THIELEN

June 3, 2025

Banner-June-2025.jpg

It’s no secret that organized religion is in trouble. Over the past few decades the American church has seen a free fall in membership, attendance, and reputation. Current data suggests the steep decline has stabilized for now. But the long-term trajectory doesn’t look particularly promising.

Given these sobering realities, almost everyone involved in the life of the American church is asking, “Where do we go from here?” There’s no singular answer to that question. If you scout out today’s religious environment, you’ll see churches taking a wide variety of paths. I’ll briefly review five of them in this month’s post.

1. Maintain the Status Quo

As usual, most churches are trying to maintain the status quo. And it’s easy to understand why. It’s what we know. It keeps us in our comfort zones. It’s the path of least resistance. It avoids change and conflict. And most churches, even those in decline, can survive in a status-quo mode for a very long time.

Of course, if the current status quo is vibrant and healthy, it makes sense to maintain it—as long as churches regularly evaluate themselves and make adjustments as needed. However, for stagnant congregations, maintaining the status quo can be costly.

Years ago, I had a long conversation with a Vietnam War vet. He told me, “When I first went to Vietnam, I had a clear sense of mission—to save the world from communism. But as the weeks and months progressed and I saw the insanity of the war, I developed a new mission—to survive another day.”

That same dynamic happens to many congregations. They begin with a keen sense of mission to reach people for Christ and church and to serve their community in significant ways. But over the years they slowly lose sight of their original animating vision. Their new purpose becomes institutional survival. Like that Vietnam vet, they are simply trying to “survive another day.”

When a church hits survival mode, the primary goal becomes retaining enough people to sustain a few programs, keep up the building, and pay the bills. Surviving another day is hardly a mission worthy of our time and energy. Still, large numbers of congregations choose to maintain the status quo for as long as possible rather than make difficult adjustments.

 

2. Shift Right

The data is clear. Most American churches and churchgoers are conservative, both theologically and politically. For example, Ryan Burge (a political scientist and data analyst who studies religion) discovered that from 2008 to 2018, 27 out of 34 Christian traditions surveyed became more conservative, including most mainline denominations. This rightward trend, which has been brewing for decades, has only accelerated since then.

As a result, far more Americans are looking for conservative congregations than liberal ones. Given this reality, shifting right can be a smart move for churches seeking to reach this large cohort of traditional believers. Although I’m not theologically conservative and disagree with many of their positions, for churches with a genuinely conservative worldview, making a rightward theological shift can be authentic, appropriate, and strategic.

While shifting right theologicallycan be justified, shifting right politically is fraught with danger. However, in today’s highly politicized environment, the temptation to do so is strong. Especially when you are in the majority. And, at least in the religious world, conservative Republicans are definitely in the majority.

As Gallup senior scientist Frank Newport reported in 2023, “Everything else being equal, the more religious the individual in the U.S. today, the higher the probability that the individual identifies with or leans toward the Republican party.”  That’s even more true in 2025.

As Ryan Burge recently wrote, “There’s plenty of evidence that American religion is now inextricably linked to one political viewpoint.” In case you’re wondering, he’s not talking about Democrats. And according to Burge’s research, the relatively small percentage of Democrats who attend church on a regular basis tends to be fairly conservative. As Burge notes, “The more Democrats go to church, the more they look like Republicans.”

In response to this clear partisan preference among today’s churchgoers, some American congregations are openly identifying with conservative GOP politics. For example, in my home state of Tennessee, a small but growing number of churches have experienced dramatic growth in recent years by intentionally becoming unabashed Trump-loving MAGA churches.

I’m obviously not recommending this option. Partisan MAGA religion  violates every value I hold as a Christian, an American, and a human being. It’s also the antithesis of everything Jesus stood for. But, at least in my neck of the (red) woods, MAGA religion can fill pews. Tragically, some churches, sensing the conservative political mood of most American churchgoers, are making this toxic partisan shift, especially among evangelical nondenominational megachurches.

 

3. Shift Left

Although small in number, some churches are intentionally shifting left. While that may seem counterintuitive in today’s religiously conservative environment, it actually makes sense. Yes, the vast majority of churchgoing Americans (evangelical, mainline, and Catholic) are conservative. But a good number of people in almost every community still want and need a progressive expression of Christian faith. And since few viable progressive congregations exist, some churches have decided to make liberal-minded people their niche and have thrived as a result.

For example, I once served a United Methodist church in an overwhelmingly conservative, GOP, evangelical, “Bible-Belt” community with large numbers of religious-right congregations. After a lot of conversation and reflection, we decided to provide an alternative. We boldly embraced and unapologetically communicated our identity as a center-left mainline congregation of “Open Hearts, Open Minds, and Open Doors.”

If anything, we underestimated the need for a progressive religious option in our town. Over the next ten years we gained more than a thousand new members (adults and children) and more than doubled our attendance. Large numbers of people who had given up on religious-right churches decided to give us a try. And a significant percentage of them stayed. For more information about this story see “How a Two-Hundred-Year-Old, Declining Mainline Church Got Its Groove Back”and “You Need to Find a Niche.”

Clearly, not every church can or should shift leftward. This only works when it represents the core identity of the congregation and when the community dynamics are right. And, just as shifting politically right damages the soul of a church, so does shifting politically left. In short, the world does not need partisan churches, left or right.

However, when a congregation can authentically offer healthy progressive theology, along with a (nonpartisan) commitment to living out the social implications of the gospel, positive results can occur. Most churches are not good candidates for this path. But for some congregations, shifting left can be a life-giving strategy, both for themselves and their community.

 

4. Become an “Unchurch”

I’m old enough to remember the creative advertising campaign for 7-UP in the late 1960s and early 1970s. The point of the “Uncola” campaign, including the unique “Uncola Man,” was to differentiate 7-UP from Coke and Pepsi. The ads communicated the message that 7-UP was not a cola—and proud of it. In short, they provided an “Uncola” alternative to traditional soft drinks.

A similar movement is happening in today’s religious marketplace. Creative faith leaders around the country are offering their communities an assortment of “Unchurch” options. One example is the house church movement, which offers people an intimate, informal, and noninstitutional experience of Christian community.

As noted before, I’m currently part of a home-based progressive retired clergy group which serves, for all practical purposes, as a house church for our members. This unique group has become a rich experience of Christian community. As one of our members recently said, “This group is more ‘church’ to me than traditional church ever was.”

Another example of the “Unchurch” movement is congregations that seek to live out what Brian McLaren calls “stage four” faith. According to McLaren, stage-four faith is post-doctrinal. It’s not about religious beliefs but about living a life of love. This expression of faith minimizes doctrines, embraces paradox, exudes humility, welcomes diversity, cares about the common good, and seeks to live out “faith that expresses itself in love.”

According to McLaren, stage-four faith communities need to be “big on action, big on love, small on beliefs, and small on bureaucracy.” Unfortunately, few established churches are willing to make the shift to “stage-four” faith communities. But some will. And a growing number of new churches seek to emulate this model.

I’m no expert on this subject. All my pastorates were in traditional churches. But I do know this: If a “stage-four” church existed in my community, I’d be part of it. In fact, after retirement, I considered starting this kind of “Unchurch” in my town. I was going to call it “Friends for the Journey.” It would have targeted the “spiritual but not religious” crowd. But in the end, I decided to put my retirement energy into a writing ministry instead, including Doubter’s Parish.

It’s beyond the scope of this article (and my expertise) to lay out principles and strategies for an “Unchurch” model of Christian community. But for those visionary leaders trying to create places like this, I’m rooting for you. Given the discouraging state of institutional religion in America, we desperately need alternative models for doing church in the twenty-first century.

 

5. Die with Dignity

After years of struggle, some churches finally come to the conclusion that they are no longer sustainable. So they decide to die with dignity. Part of that process is choosing a satisfying strategy for dispersing their facilities and financial resources. An important part of dying with dignity is holding a final worship service where the congregation acknowledges their loss but also celebrates the many contributions they have made.

Several years ago, I received an invitation to the final worship service of a small congregation I once briefly served. Since I was unable to attend, I sent a letter to the congregation to be read by the district superintendent. In the letter I shared some of my good memories of the church. Then I wrote the following words:

I’m sure today is a difficult time for you. It’s hard to close a church. But every congregation, like every person, has a life cycle of birth, growth, maturity, decline, and death. It’s the natural order of life. Even the churches of the New Testament came to an end.

However, churches never really die. Every person who has ever been connected to this good church carries the congregation with them for the rest of their lives. Every member and friend touched by you over the years, including me, has been forever enriched by your faithfulness.

May God’s blessing be with you on this eventful day. And even in your sadness, I hope you will always be grateful for—and celebrate—all the years you served God and your community, and the many lives you have touched. Please remember that these kinds of kingdom contributions never fade away in the eyes of God.

These five possible paths for 21st century churches—retain the status quo, shift right, shift left, become an “unchurch,” and die with dignity—are certainly not exhaustive. But they do represent a few of the ways congregations are navigating today’s uncertain times. If you would like to share additional paths you see congregations taking, including your own, please send me an email. I always love hearing from Doubter’s Parish readers.

 

AUTHOR’S NOTE

To share this post, please click the appropriate icon at the bottom of the page. If you would like to communicate with me, feel free to send an email and I’ll respond as soon as possible. To receive my monthly newsletter(a brief email notification alerting you to new posts and other materials), please do so today. Thank you for your interest in Doubter’s Parish. Writing for you is a joy.

@ Copyright - Martin Thielen & Doubter's Parish

You need to be a member of The Reimagine.Network to add comments!

Join The Reimagine.Network

Email me when people reply –

BONUS Content >>>SCROLL for RELATED COMMENTARY by GUEST-POSTERS + FEATURED CONTRIBUTORS

  • CREATE THE ATMOSPHERE, PART 2: "SEVEN MARKS OF A JESUS COMMUNITY"
    By Larry Doornbos

     

    Last week, I began writing about terraforming, the process of taking an environment hostile to human life and reshaping it so it that life can thrive there. Spiritually speaking, churches engage in the work of terraforming too.

    • Terraforming congregations intentionally design their life together to be places where the atmosphere leads them to join God’s mission for the good of the world, the good of the congregation, and God’s glory. Michael Rhodes, in his insightful book Reimagining Biblical Politics, writes that God’s people are called to arrange their life together in ways that “make our king’s reign and way visible and attractive to the watching world.” The way we make decisions, steward power, interact with outsiders, and share resources ought to exert a “gravitational pull” on those around us, drawing them toward God’s kingdom.
    In our last article, we explored the marks of a Torah community. Now let’s look at the marks of a Jesus community. Bringing together the ways of these two communities will help us terraform our churches well.

    SEVEN MARKS OF A JESUS COMMUNITY

    1. ENCOUNTER JESUS
    • A Jesus community is a place where people encounter the teaching, miracle-working, crucified, risen, and ascended Jesus. They encounter Jesus as the Messiah and rightful King of the world.
    • Is your congregation creating opportunities for people to encounter Jesus, not simply learn about him, but come to know, trust, and follow him?
    2. BECOME A PEOPLE OF WISDOM, COMPASSION, AND JUSTICE
    • The Jesus community is marked by wisdom (see James and the Sermon on the Mount) and by compassion and justice (Matthew 23:23; Matthew 25; Luke 18). Its prayers are marked by cries for wisdom (James 1:5) and justice. Martin Luther reminds us that when we pray, “Give us this day our daily bread,” we are also praying for a just society where people can earn their bread without exploitation.
    • How can your congregation pursue wisdom, compassion, and justice in both its prayers and practices?
    3. DRAW THE NATIONS IN
    • The Jesus community goes out into the world, proclaiming and showing the ways of God, and so draws in the nations (Matthew 28; Acts). It does not exist simply for the benefit of its members, but for the good of the world God loves.
    • How can your congregation become more intentional about going into the community, demonstrating God’s ways, and inviting others into his kingdom?
    4. CREATE AN ATMOSPHERE OF FORGIVENESS AND LOVE
    • A hallmark of the Jesus community is an atmosphere of forgiveness. The community knows God’s forgiveness and extends it to one another, to those outside the community, and even to enemies. Above all, the community understands that its primary way in the world is love (1 John 3; Colossians 3; Galatians 5; Luke 6).
    • How can your church become a place where forgiveness is freely extended, enemies are loved, and people experience the love of Jesus through his followers?
    5. CULTIVATE JOY AND GRATITUDE
    • Jesus tells his community that they have received freely, so they should give freely (Matthew 10). The celebration of the Eucharist, the Samaritan who returns to thank Jesus for his healing, and the blind beggar who praises God all reflect a joyful, grateful community.
    • How can your congregation make gratitude, generosity, and celebration defining characteristics of its life together?
    6. BECOME AN UPSIDE-DOWN AND GENEROUS COMMUNITY
    • Throughout the New Testament, the community of Jesus is upside-down. The last will be first, the poor are filled while the rich are sent away empty, and Jesus lifts up women, children, and the marginalized. This community does not store up treasures on earth but willingly shares what it has, living in solidarity with the least. Knowing the generosity of Jesus, its members give generously to others, even in poverty (2 Corinthians 8–9).
    • How can your congregation demonstrate these upside-down values through the ways you share resources, welcome people, and care for those in need?
    7. LIVE AS A SENT COMMUNITY
    • The Jesus community is a city on a hill, sent into the world to radiate mercy, love, peace, justice, generosity, and deliverance. This is a community that loves enemies and even labors alongside enemies for their shalom (see Jeremiah 29).
    • How can your congregation move beyond its walls to seek the peace and flourishing of its neighbors, demonstrating the good news of God’s kingdom through both words and actions?
    Terraforming congregations take up the marks of the Jesus community and strive to create a life together as God’s ambassadors, telling and embodying God’s story to the world. Which of these marks most needs attention in your congregation? What could you begin doing now to create an atmosphere that honors Jesus as King and demonstrates his compassion, peacemaking, healing, justice, and, above all, love?
    Thank you for joining us on our mission of church renewal. 
    Do you know anyone who would like to receive our weekly newsletter? 
    Here is a link that they can use to subscribe.
    We would love to add you to our CCR Friends group.
    Friends receive updates on renewal ministry
    along with stories from the churches.
    Click here and hit "Send" to be added to our list.
    We are grateful to God and to you for allowing us to partner with you in renewing churches.  
    Might you consider investing in the Center for Church Renewal?  
    To make your tax-deductible donation please click here. 
    Thank you for supporting this important work.
    The Center for Church Renewal seeks to serve leaders
    who are renewing churches. a

     

This reply was deleted.