Transition to a Deep-and-Wide Discipleship Spectrum
by Phil Miglioratti @ Reimagine.Network
Transition to Deep and Wide Spectrum Discipleship- Print with Page Breaks.docx
Worksheets -Transition to Deep and Wide Spectrum Discipleship.docx
Discipleship Specturm-Graphic & Handout.pdf
Power-Point Discipleship-Spectrum_with_graphic.pptx
Guest-Post (scroll to comments) -Transformational DiscipleMaking by Dennis Owen, Transformation Louisville
Jesus has given every Christian, every congregation, and every ministry an identical commission:
"As you go, make disciples."
Yet, across the continuum of global Christianity, our methods and models are vastly different.
A variety of learning styles are employed and our teaching systems are based on diverse objectives, chosen for their effectiveness in a specific culture or tradition.
Each stream/branch of the Christian faith utilizes a particular set of patterns and programs that tend to produce disciples strong in one specific area of theology or ministry mode.
This pervasive practice is both our problem and our solution.
_______________________________________________
Transition: unlearn the Typical “First Question”
Our Problem ---
Congregations, even denominations, tend to build their disciplemaking programs on a single focus or format. As good as their approach may be, it cannot produce a complete, a fully mature, disciple. Exclusivity, or even too much emphasis on a single model, results in a narrow or formulated message, a reliance on a singular method which cannot be suited to every believer's gifting and personality, and/or a truncated comprehension of our mission.
Our Solution ---
Disciplers on all levels (local, denominational, organizational) must widen their scope of the learning process by looking-listening-learning from other ministry streams with the objective of incorporating or collaborating with models birthed from different perspectives that employ dissimilar methods.
Each system on the spectrum of Christian disciplemaking is an essential building block.
But, no one style is comprehensive.
The story of the blind men and the elephant is a parable that illustrates how limited perspectives can lead to incomplete understandings.
In the story, several blind people encounter an elephant for the first time.
Each person touches a different part of the elephant – the leg, the trunk, the ear, the tail, the tusk – and based on their limited experience,
they each form a different idea of what the elephant is like.
One thinks it's like a pillar, another a snake, another a fan, and another a rope, another pipe. LibreTexts
The parable highlights the dangers of not considering multiple perspectives
and the importance of seeking a more comprehensive understanding of any situation.
Jesus did not limit his disciplemaking to a single method. He modeled dissimilar approaches utilizing varied activities and experiences.
Think of each format as a tool in a toolbox. Each instrument is designed for a specific task or objective. No single tool can be used for every repair nor is it capable of single-handedly completing all the tasks of a building project. A hammer is essential but for that toolbox to be a resource for the builder/repair person, it must also contain a variety of additional devices, such as a tape measure, an adjustable wrench, a knife or saw, and a selection of screwdrivers from a variety of styles and sizes.
Our model of making disciples must shift from employing a single model, believing it to be foundational, to incorporating a deep-and-wide spectrum of models.
- Deep: radical thinking; “to the roots” of an idea
- Wide: full-range; from one end to the other
The different expressions (churches, denominations, ministries, movements) that comprise the arms and legs, and eyes and ears, of the Body of Christ are not in competition with one another. We must not protect (or be limited to) our preferred theories or strategies of making believers into disciples. Nor should we ignore how other segments of the Church are equipping their members to emulate Christ. We are meant to learn from other approaches and share ideas with one another, even those with theological differences.
______________________________
"The church, though, has a responsibility to shape people for the future—their future and the future of those in their area of influence.
In that sense, the call for the church is not so much to figure out how to speak the grammar of TikTok or of whatever follows it.
It’s to realize that our cultural grammars are shaping us, forming us, discipling us, right down to the questions we ask.
We don’t simply need answers for questioning seekers—although we need that.
We need forms of mentoring, modeling, and internal culture that are counter-algorithms.
We need “Thus saith the Lord,” and we also need what Jesus taught us: “Take heed how you hear” (Luke 8:18, ESV).
Lots of things Jesus said to us are countercultural.
One of the hardest, for the years ahead, might be words that some of us skipped right over: “Pay attention.”"
Moore to the Point in Christianity Today
_______________________________________
Transition: ReThink the First Question
Recognizing our need to unlearn certain aspects of our perception of making a disciple, also requires us to rethink a foundational question that is seldom asked. Most streams or branches, denominations or ministries have developed their systems and programs based on the question: “What do believers need to learn?” which is a crucial question but NOT the initial inquiry.
Each stop along the spectrum must first ask what hsould have been the obvious starting point: “How do human beings learn?” and “How do people learn?”
- “How do human beings learn?” is a quest to understand how our minds function (biology, chemistry, psychology)
- “How do people learn?” is a quest to recognize how society, ethnicity, and technology shape knowledge acquisition
#Rethink How the Learning Process Has Changed
Human beings instinctively learn by:
observing, watching, imitating, hearing, listening, repeating, asking, reading, playing, talking, pondering.
People learn with the assistance of:
teachers, instructors, mentors, counselors, guides, coaches, facilitators, who employ discussion, dialogue, experimentation, exploration, sensory experience, feedback/correction, challenge.
The goal is for each believer to become a life-long learner, a self-motivated student of God’s Truth, a mature follower of our Lord Jesus, a humble servant to the Body of Christ, a wise discipler of other believers, an enthusiastic (“in; theos”) worshipper, a servant-leader to the church – at work – in the community.
Every disciple
…must be taught truths but also trained in how to discover those truths for themselves and how to practice them in their life.
…must be introduced to answers (beliefs, doctrines) but also encouraged to ask questions, in their personal walk with Christ (prayer and study) and in their participation with the Body of Christ (worship, fellowship, discipleship, stewardship, leadership).
…needs to be guided into experiences that build faith, hope, and love, and equip them to fulfill their calling by the Spirit-empowered use of their spiritual gifts.
…should be maturing in their expression of the character of Christ as they learn to live by the fruit of the Spirit and live in accountability to their faith community.
…ought to recognize their responsibility to be a discipler of disciplers.
____________________
People who don’t go to church say they experience God in nature, art, meditation, social action, study, and other people.
Jeremy; a “skeptic pastor”
_________________________________
Transition: Widen Your Horizon
Which of these models/methods do you utilize in disciplemaking?
Which of these components of learning are missing from your teaching? Educational settings? Lifestyle experiences?
- Incorporation -ritual based experiences: ceremonial observances, spiritual exercises, emotional worship, mystical experiences, annual activities or holidays
* Christening, Baptism, Catechism, Confirmation
- Indoctrination -memorized scripture, learned templates (“Four Laws,” three-point sermons) repetitive teaching, reciting creeds, chanting, stained glass windows, hymns
* Tracts, The Lord’s Prayer, Doxology, Pslams and Hymns
- Education -teacher generated presentations of information (dogma, statues, history, theology)
* Sunday School, Sermons, Seminars
- Instruction -training and coaching on how to implement spiritual practices and skills: how to pray, read and study the Bible, share the message of Jesus
* Workshops, Conferences, Training Sessions
- Investigation -a question driven pursuit of basic theological and philosophical concepts
* God, Salvation, Ecclesiology, etc...
- Meditation -learning to be still and silent while seeking to be filled by the Spirit; learning the ways of the Spirit
* Prayer, Journaling, Prayerwalking
- Formation -personal counseling for application/problem-solving/wisdom
* Spiritual Direction, Pastoral Counseling, Christian Counseling
- Conversation -group discussion/study/ interaction
* Small Groups, Summer Camp, Vacation Bible School, Youth Group, Women's/Men's Ministry
- Exploration -modeling and practicing in life experiences (praying for/with, caring/serving, sharing faith)
* Prayer Stations, Community Action, Advocacy Ministry
- Evangelization - proclaiming the Gospel: story or sermon, dialogue or debate, social media
* Friendship or Prayer-Care-Share, or Event Evangelism, Justice, Ministry to the Poor
- Commission -appointing/sending into personal ministry of making disciples
* Missionary (at work-our community-another country), Ministry Team Leader, Elder, “Clergy”
My Journey Across the Specturm
> I was taught Bible stories by fundamentalists
> I learned Bible study with evangelicals
> As a teenage believer, I was given leadership roles by a children’s ministry organization
> Not long after I was invited by a campus ministry to speak in evangelistic gatherings
> I grappled with biblical theology systems by professors ranging from Calvinism to Arminianism
> A mega-church gave me the opportunity to design and build a ministry to children based on the biblical promises of God
> A Southern Baptist initiative on church planting gave me unexpected opportunities to teach and author content and lead
> Vineyard pastors exposed me to worship that was singing to God, not just about God
> Interdenominational Prayer Groups introduced me to responsive praying
> Charismatic teachers taught me the role of the Holy Spirit in praying
> A Baptist professor opened my eyes to the role of the Spirit in counseling
> An Evangelical Free Church leader taught me how to facilitate, rather than dominate, small group gatherings
> Servant leaders from a coalition of denominations involved me in “citywide” church collaboration
> Missionaries and local ministry leaders in Zambia, Guatemala, Mexico, Costa Rica revealed the need to recognize cultural components of Christian ministry and mission
> The Evangelical Covenant Church introduced me to “high” church worship
> The Roman Catholic Church opened my eyes to the majesty and mystery of ritual and liturgy.
> Along the way, I have interacted with colleagues from various denominations who lived reverent, reflective lives of meditation and deep reflection
__________________________________
Transition: ReExamine Scripture
“Continue to grow and increase in God’s grace and intimacy with our Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ. May he receive all the glory both now and until the day eternity begins. Amen!”
2 Peter 3:18 TPT
“They all train God’s people to serve so that the Body of Christ will be built up, until we are all united in our faith and our knowledge of God’s Son and we become grown up, mature, and completely filled with Christ.”
Ephesians 4:12-13 RAD
“My friends, stop thinking like children. Think like mature people and be as innocent as tiny babies.”
1 Corinthians 14:20 CEV
“Solid food is for the mature, whose spiritual senses perceive heavenly matters. And they have been adequately trained by what they’ve experienced to emerge with understanding of the difference between what is truly excellent and what is evil and harmful.”
Hebrews 5:14 TPT
____________________________________________________
Transition: ReFormat Your DiscipleMaking Ministry
- Pray
- Ask for God to reveal the strengths of your biblical theology of discipleship as well as the weaknesses of your practical theories of making disciples.
- Seek the Spirit’s leading for how to repent, ( ie, change your mindset, not feel sorry).
- Knock on doors by pursuing new ideas, new ways, new partners, to equip your people through a deep-and-wide spectrum of disciplemaking approaches and activities.
- Assess
- Objectively assess what your people respond to as well as what your programs and practices fail to provide for their maturing in Christ.
- unLearn
- Identity programs and practices that need to be retired or reshaped and begin to reset how you communicate to your leadership/planning team.
- Reimagine with your people
- Invite leadership to widen their perspective; lead them through a review of each component on the discipleship spectrum with the goal of designing action plans to revise each segment by resetting/reshaping existing programs.
- Reformat your ministry
- Pray for the courage to implement the re-forms the Spirit has revealed to expand your ministry across the full spectrum of disciplemaking options.
- Rebrand the process
- Publish and proclaim the models and methods across the spectrum … the role of the church … the responsibilities of the disciple … the presence and power of the dwelling Holy Spirit to coach and teach and equip … celebrate examples of believers becoming disciplers
____________________________________________________
Transition: ReAssess Your DiscipleMaking MindSet
How do we provide believers a variety of contexts which will build them into mature followers of Christ?
Identity Describe Best Setting for Their Nurture
-Disciple -
-Student -
-Followers -
-Intern -
-Mentee -
-Learner -
-Apprentice -
-Worshipper -
-Believer -
How do people learn in our disciplemaking programs?
“How humans learn” “How people learn” in our system
Observe -
Listen -
Memorize/Repeat -
Imitate -
Read -
Reflect/Ponder -
Ask -
Converse -
Watch -
Play -
Sense -
Experience -
Experiment -
Practice -
Teach/Train Others -
Identify persons in your ministry who function in these roles:
*Teachers –
*Instructors –
*Mentors –
*Counselors -
*Guides –
*Coaches –
*Facilitators –
*Other -
How do we equip our disciplers to utilize these methods:
*Discussion -
*Dialogue –
*Experimentation –
*Exploration –
*Sensory Experiences –
*Feedback/Correction –
*Challenge –
*Other -
_________________________________________________
Transition: ReNew Your DiscipleMaking Options
For Discussion with Your Leadership
- How to we apply this insight/idea to our situation?
- What program/activity/meeting group do we need to retire?
- What event/experience do we need to add?
- What conference/seminar/gathering can we add to our spectrum options?
Discipleship cannot be just about biblical content; it must develop spiritual character and a missional lifestyle.
Discipleship is more than consuming information; disciplers must become lifetime learners.
A spectrum: a continuum of models & methods, perspectives & programs, activities adventures & as well as distinct courses of specialized study.
In order for you to grow new believers into a mature, disciples, they need more than the one-thing model that fits you well or a method you prefer or fall into by default. To become a mature disciple, everyone needs to explore and experience a variety of disciplemaking modes. People don’t learn from a single teaching technique. The learning spectrum is wide to accommodate different learning preferences and to give every learner pathways that challenge them to become deep-and-wide in their faith.
Ask for guidance to discern your skill set is for making mature disciples. Then ask seek knock. What can your group/team/congregation add to that. Then go beyond it to think of outside of your church walls, what resources are available from other congregations, from other ministries, seminars, workshops, mission organizations?
Pastor asked: “Can one church provide the full spectrum discipleship?
My response: “Yes but not your church. It takes the Church across your city. The varied and diverse Body of Christ. Unity is not total doctrinal agreement; it is Spirit-led, Scripture-fed teamwork.”
Denominational and divisions keep us from full spectrum discipleship.
Our view that our brand is inspired (100% correct) and other brands are not means they have nothing to offer.
Full spectrum discipleship is a mission that includes diverse models and different methods we must m combine and coordinate into a system that involves the disciple in as many as their calling and gifting demand. No one model is comprehensive enough to nurture a complete Christ follower.
Your preferred model or method of disciplemaking is not foundational, it is a component of the fuller spectrum of strategies and systems. Our foundation is the Word of God revealed on Scripture and prayer and obedience.
Limitations of AI in Education:
- Emotional intelligence:
AI lacks the capacity to understand and respond to the nuances of human emotions, which are crucial for building relationships with students and fostering a positive learning environment.
- Contextual understanding:
AI struggles to grasp the complex social and cultural contexts of the classroom, including student dynamics and individual learning needs.
- Critical thinking and creativity:
While AI can generate text and provide information, it cannot replicate the human ability to think critically, solve problems creatively, and inspire students to do the same.
- Human interaction:
Teachers play a vital role in fostering a sense of community, providing encouragement, and building relationships with students, which are essential for their overall well-being and academic success. Beverly R. Green * Patheos
______________________
Pray for Mature Disciples
Epaphras sends you greetings. He is one of you and is a servant of Christ Jesus. He always talks to God about you with all his heart. He asks God to help you to be strong so that you will become grown-up Christians and know all that God wants you to do.
I myself have seen how hard he has worked for you and for the people in the cities of Laodicea and Hierapolis.
Colossians 4:12-13
>>>KEEP SCROLLING for RELATED CONTENT & COMMENTARY, RESOURCES & REPLIES
MORE ... From Phil's Reimagine FIles - -
#ReimagineDISCIPLESHIP
"Get Used To Different." Rethink the DNA of Discipleship
#Reimagine...How the Learning Process Has Changed Learning
#ReimagineDISCIPLESHIP...Educating in the Technological, Post-Pande...
#ReimagineDISCIPLESHIP...as Developing a Biblical Worldview
#ReimaginePRAYER... to #ReimagineDISCIPLESHIP... Biblically.
#ReimagineDISCIPLESHIP... Developing a Prayer Culture
#ReimagineDISCIPLESHIP...My Confession About Confession
Syncretism Breeds Pharisees
#ReimagineDISCIPLESHIP...According to The Jesus:Ratios
#ReimagineDISCIPLESHIP...as choosing Scripture over Culture
#ReimagineDISCIPLESHIP...additional posts on Twitter
Generosity Is In Your DNA
Loving the 'Ville like Jesus does so that our city will be forever changed.
Transformation Louisville
Cell 904-302-3395
dpowen1@hotmail.com
#Reassess
Is your discipleship answering "the practical question about life with God?"
•How is your new knowledge helping you pray?
•What are you learning that has opened your heart more deeply to the Lord?
•How is your education leading you to love God with your whole heart, and to love your neighbor as yourself?"
Kyle Strobel
FEATURED CONTRIBUTOR ~ Bob Tolliver